While I would certainly not call myself a "gun expert", I have done a lot of reading in the various online forums, have read self defense and concealed carry books (The Gun Digest Book of Concealed Carry is very good), have taken a few classes, and eventually, formed a few opinions about concealed carry that I'd like to share. Hopefully, my thoughts will save you some time and research.
Remember of course that while there are many subjects that most concealed carry license (CCL) holders will agree on, there are also many subjects where opinions will differ, sometimes a lot, so of course my thoughts are debatable.
My goal for concealed carry is to carry daily (which means being convenient/comfortable is a big plus), while using a concealed carry weapon (CCW) that is reasonably effective for the purpose of stopping/deterring a bad guy, in the situations I most frequently imagine I will be in.
My thought was that if carrying isn't easy and convenient, I will be tempted now and then, to leave my CCW at home, where it will do no good. It's better to carry almost ANY gun, ALL the time, than to have NO gun because it's a bit too heavy or bulky, or takes too long to strap on, etc, which results in the user leaving their CCW at home.
The best CCW is the one you have WITH you, and know how to use.
I am about 5'10", and 165 pounds. Both a smaller and a larger person may find another choice of CCW, or way of carrying it, that suits them better. Also, I carry in a town where I feel reasonably safe most of the time. If I carried in more threatening environs with some frequency, I might choose to carry more firepower, meaning a greater number of rounds and/or a larger caliber. And indeed, sometimes I carry my Glock 26.
So in choosing the best carry setup, there are really only two considerations:
1) Weapon choice.
2) Method of carry.
WEAPON CHOICE
A larger caliber weapon is typically thought to always have an advantage over a smaller caliber weapon, all else being equal. But all else is never equal.
I chose 380.
Yes, some will say 380 does not have enough stopping power, and that 9mm, or even larger, is "the minimum". But I feel confident that when a bad guy is getting shot at, a 380 is going to make him run away as fast as anything, and if STOPPING him is the goal, 380 is going hurt quite a bit, especially with decent shot placement (practice!).
A CCW must also be very reliable. Reliable meaning it will go BANG when you pull the trigger, and cycle properly to get the next round chambered. This typically means choosing a good brand name, and for me, meant reading reviews to feel confident the particular model is indeed working reliably for the vast majority of users.
I chose a Ruger LCP. Very good reviews, and very small.
Some might say, "it only carries 7 rounds...6 in the magazine and 1 in the chamber...and I might need more." Yes, but more means a bigger/heavier weapon...which again, increases the chances I will leave it at home. (I might add here that for someone who prefers a revolver, the Ruger LCR is a great choice (no, I don't work for or have any affiliation with Ruger). It's a bit bigger than the LCP, but still quite small...though pocket carry would be problematic, at least for me).
Some will say, "the trigger isn't the greatest", which is in my humble opinion, an important, though relatively minor complaint for a CCW. (By-the-way, I find the trigger to be just fine.) For the purpose of concealed carry, I was not looking for the CCW to be the best at everything...you won't find that anyway...many have tried unsuccessfully. And in any case, I am not using my CCW for championship target shooting. I just want my CCW to go BANG reliably, sending lead downrange with decent accuracy. THAT'S IT. If the trigger isn't perfect, SO BE IT, it doesn't have to be. And, there will be so much adrenaline flowing in you if you ever have the need to fire your weapon, you are not going to notice the finer qualities of the trigger.
A lesser concern, though worth mentioning, is felt recoil. No one wants too much. It's debatable, of course, how much is too much. But less recoil allows the user to bring the barrel back on target more quickly after a shot. There are a few easy-to-carry 9mm handguns that are not much bigger than the LCP, like for example, the Kel-Tec PF-9, but the Kel-Tec has a lot more felt recoil. Yes, it has more stopping power, but that extra recoil makes it harder to get the 2nd and 3rd shots, etc., back on target. I would rather have better shot placement with a 380, than be missing the target with a tiny 9mm with lots of recoil. That said, a somewhat larger 9mm, like a Glock 26 (excellent handgun), has much less felt recoil than a PF-9. The Ruger LC9 is sized in between those two, and is another good choice in 9mm.
Here is a spreadsheet of popular 9mm carry weapons for a quick size comparison, along with the 380 caliber Ruger LCP, and the .45 caliber Springfield XD-S (small! nice!) listed alphabetically. Click image for a larger view:
All that said, I applaud those who carry larger/heavier firearms and do it every day. Bravo. Yes, bravo.
METHOD OF CARRY
There are several choices, divided into two basic categories...on body, which are holsters strapped to you, and off body, like fanny packs, purses, etc. Some on-body options include inside-the-waistband (IWB), outside-the-waistband (OWB), ankle carry and shoulder holster, while off-body options include fanny packs, purses, and several more.
I chose pocket carry, with a pocket holster. The pocket holster disguises the shape of the gun, and protects the trigger from accidental firing.
The advantages of pocket carry for me are:
1) I can just grab the LCP and walk out the door...I don't have to thread a holster thru my belt, or clip something on, etc...details that may make me walk out the door WITHOUT my CCW if I was in a big hurry. Ease of removing my CCW is important too, like when I might want to enter a place where concealed carry is not legal. Pocket carry makes that quick and simple. Yes there are other holsters that are pretty easy too, but it's hard to beat pocket carry.
2) Like most of us, I have my hands in my pockets from time to time...which places my hand ON my CCW...this makes for a very quick draw (but remember, practice!). Also, having my hands in my pockets raises no suspicion to someone who may be looking at me. I find it an interesting/good feeling to have my hand ON my gun while otherwise looking completely normal.
3) I don't have to buy pants that are 1 or 2 inches too big to allow for IWB (inside the waistband) carry.
4) I don't have to worry about someone walking up behind me and grabbing my CCW, like they just might if they got a glimpse my CCW, say, strapped to my belt (under a shirt or jacket) as it would be with OWB (outside the waistband) carry. My front pocket is much more secure.
5) I know, all the time, the state of concealment of my CCW. It's in my front pocket, virtually invisible to onlookers, and I can glance down at any time to make sure. That "knowing" would NOT be so clear if my CCW was on my belt, using IWB or OWB carry (and being carried in the typical 3:30 to 4:30 position, which would be on my right side, slightly around toward my back). I couldn't easily know, on a moment to moment basis, if, say, my shirt or jacket crept up a bit on my body, exposing my CCW to anyone who cared to look.
6) Pocket holsters are very cheap...I use this Uncle Mike's (size 2) But whatever holster you choose, buy something well built...spend the money up front, and never look back.
Now...
All that said, there are lots of folks who will say that other ways of carrying are just as comfortable, just as convenient, etc., etc. Those opinions are all valid. And also, a person must consider their most likely situation where they might need to draw. For example, it's not easy to draw while sitting, using pocket carry. But for me, on an everyday basis, pocket carry still wins.
TO SUMMARIZE:
I wanted an easy-to-grab, comfortable-to-carry, reliable, and reasonably-effective-at-it's-intended-purpose, concealed-carry weapon. And if all that wasn't too expensive, so much the better. Turns out the Ruger LCP and a pocket holster can be had for about $325 total.
Easy to grab: pocket carry.
Comfortable to carry: lightweight and small CCW.
Reliable: Ruger LCP.
Reasonably effective caliber for it's intended purpose: 380
OTHER THOUGHTS:
LASER:
Lasers are not cheap, but I really like the flexibility they give the user in not having to look down the barrel to sight in a target. You can hold your CCW at your side (if you have to), or in other non-standard firing positions, and if you can see the laser painting the target, all you need to do is squeeze the trigger.
This could be quite useful if, say, you are crouched down behind something, or around a corner from the target. If you can stick your hand out in the clear, and glimpse the laser painting the target, you won't have to expose your head or whole body to the line of fire to get an accurate shot off. I chose the Crimson Trace Laserguard.
Real life stories from the Crimson Trace website.
SECURING YOUR FIREARM AT HOME:
Each individual will have to consider just how secure their gun needs to be in their home, so that children, or anyone who does not know how to properly operate the firearm, or might do harm to themselves or others, can not access or operate the gun.
But any securing of the firearm is going to add a bit of time until YOU can access and/or operate it, so the choice you make here is dictated by having to walk a fine line between quick access and household safety.
Cost will be an issue as well, as a fancier safety system might offer better performance, but will not be cheap.
I chose a simple safe. It's enough in my home to make me feel confident that no one in the house will be able to access the gun, while at the same time giving me fairly quick access, and it didn't cost too much either.
This "Stack-On, PDS-500 Drawer Safe" is working well for me.
